The donors for Winchell’s purchase of the Ward’s cast included many of the most privileged members of Minneapolis society. Among their myriad contributions, they built the city’s streetcar network and the first bridge over the Mississippi River. They constructed the first lumber, flour, and textile mills at Saint Anthony Falls, and the nation’s first commercial hydroelectric power plant. Their numbers included governors, judges, university regents, doctors, and attorneys. Others were capitalists, mill owners, horticulturists, real estate speculators, lumbermen, railroad barons, and oddly, one humble seller of lightning rods. While many of the donors had fought for the Union, one was an ardent southern sympathizer.
Donors List
Judge E. S. Jones $ 50.00
Gov. J. S. Pillsbury 150.00
Hon. L. Butler 150.00
Dr. H. H. Kimball 10.00
R. J. Mendenhall 10.00
Hon. E. M. Wilson 10.00
Hon. R. B. Langdon 50.00
Hon. H. T. Welles 50.00
S. C. Gale, Esq. 25.00
Chute Brothers 10.00
Judge Isaac Atwater 15.00
D. S. Story 5.00
Jonathan Chase 100.00
Anthony Kelly 5.00
Wyman Elliott 5.00
Thomas Lowry 25.00
Hon. A. M. Reid 25.00
Hon. Paris Gibson 25.00
Total: $720.00
The full cost of the set was $1,500 and the regents provided $600.
Despite their wealth and power though, their combined contributions to purchase the casts only totaled $720 dollars. The university regents provided another $600, leaving Winchell $180 shy of the casts’ full purchase price of $1500. According to department lore, Winchell made up the difference by giving Ward Minnesota fossils and animal pelts.
Judge Edwin Smith Jones
Edwin Smith Jones was born in Chaplin, Connecticut on June 3, 1828, and worked as a lawyer in Connecticut. He came to Minneapolis in 1854 and joined the office of Judge Isaac Atwater, another cast donor, until 1857 when he was elected judge of probate. In 1863, Jones joined the Union forces and served as a captain, brevet major, and commissary of subsistence in the Department of the Gulf. After the Civil War, he returned to Minneapolis and served as chair of the board of county supervisors. In 1870, Jones quit law to become president of the Hennepin County Savings Bank and served two years on the city council. One of his sons, David Percy Jones, also donated archaeological materials to Winchell’s General Museum. Edwin Smith Jones died from diabetes on January 26, 1890, at his home on 2005 Third Ave. S. and was buried in Lakewood Cemetery.
Governor John Sargent Pillsbury
John Sargent Pillsbury was born in Sutton, New Hampshire on July 29, 1827. He became governor of Minnesota around the time of his donation, but Pillsbury was also the driving force behind the University of Minnesota’s rebirth in the wake of the Civil War. Pillsbury served as a regent throughout the university’s early history. His donation of $150,000 funded the building of Science Hall in 1889. That building would soon be renamed Pillsbury Hall and would become the final home of Winchell’s General Museum.
Pillsbury began as a store owner in New Hampshire but in 1855, while on a tour of the ‘West,’ he decided to make Saint Anthony his home. He married Mahala Fisk and undertook numerous ventures in hardware, real estate, and lumber before founding an immensely profitable milling concern, the Pillsbury Company. Pillsbury served in the Minnesota Senate for several years and was Minnesota’s eighth governor from January 1876 until January 1882. During his term, the Grasshopper Plague of 1877 would spark the biological and botanical efforts of Winchell’s Geological and Natural History Survey. Pillsbury’s daughter, Sarah Belle, married the son of Samuel Chester Gale, another cast donor) whose art collection helped build the Minneapolis Institute of Arts. Pillsbury died on October 18, 1901, and was buried in Lakewood Cemetery.
Levi "L." Butler
Levi Butler was born in Jennings County, Indiana on June 10, 1818, and attended Ohio Medical College. He then worked as a doctor in Dupont, Indiana. In 1855, to improve his health, Butler started to spend summers camping in Minnesota. He moved to Minnesota in 1858 and ended up purchasing many of the land tracts he had previously camped on. In 1861, Butler became surgeon of Minnesota’s Third Regiment. He served in Memphis where he contracted typhoid fever, which forced him to resign in 1865. In 1867, Butler began purchasing pine land and building a lumber mill. From 1870 to 1876, Butler served in the state senate and was chair of the railroad committee during the years when the Granger movement arose to oppose those railroads. He was later president of the Farmers’ and Mechanics’ Savings Bank and a benefactor of the Minneapolis Female Seminary. Butler died on April 14, 1878, and was buried in Lakewood Cemetery.
Dr. Hannibal Hamlin Kimball
Hannibal Hamlin Kimball was born on August 18, 1843, in Carmel, Maine and came to Minneapolis in 1867 after graduating from Bowdoin Medical College. He arrived with his friend and fellow cast donor, Thomas Lowry. The two met in Chicago and traveled by boat from Prairie du Chien, Wisconsin, which at the time was the nearest railroad terminus to the city. Although Lowry was a lawyer rather than a doctor, the two shared lodging, an office, and even formal wear, both being fortunately the same size. Shortly after his donation for Winchell’s casts, Kimball married Grace Morrison, the daughter of Minneapolis’ first mayor and the two moved to Europe for two years. There, Kimball studied in European hospitals before returning to practice once again in Minneapolis. Kimball died on July 9, 1928, and was buried in Lakewood Cemetery.
Richard Junius Mendenhall
Richard Junius Mendenhall was born on November 25, 1828, in Jamestown, North Carolina. As a young man, he worked as a surveyor for railroads in North Carolina and Ohio. Mendenhall came to Minneapolis in 1856 and the following year formed a real estate and loan partnership a childhood friend, Cyrus Beede. In 1862, Mendenhall became president of the State Bank of Minnesota and was president of the State Savings Association until the association’s suspension during the Panic of 1873. Of the cast donors, he was the only member of the Friends (Quaker) Church. Mendenhall died at his home at 1714 Stevens Avenue on October 18, 1906, and was buried in Lakewood Cemetery.
Eugene McLanahan Wilson
Eugene McLanahan Wilson was born on December 25, 1833, in Morgantown, Virginia, the son and grandson of U.S. representatives. After graduating from Jefferson College in 1852, he worked as a lawyer in Virginia until he moved to Minnesota in 1855. Wilson opened a legal practice in Winona but in 1857 he was chosen to be the United States Attorney for the District of Minnesota and moved to Minneapolis. During the Civil War, he was a captain in Company A of the 1st Minnesota Volunteer Cavalry, primarily serving in the Dakota War of 1862. After the war, Wilson was elected to Congress and served until 1870. He then returned to Minneapolis and was elected mayor in 1872 and 1874. In 1873 though, Wilson participated in the abduction of Lord Gordon Gordon, an infamous conman, from Canada at the request of Jay Gould. Wilson, Gould, Loren Fletcher, and John Gilfillan were arrested but later released on bail after diplomatic pressure by Minnesota Governor Horace Austin. Wilson served in the Minnesota Senate in 1878 and 1879 and was an unsuccessful candidate for Governor in 1888. He died of malaria on April 10, 1890, while on a visit to regain his health in Nassau, British West Indies and was buried in Lakewood Cemetery.
Robert Bruce Langdon
Robert Bruce Langdon was born on November 24, 1826, in New Haven, Vermont. He started working with railroads as a supervisor of a grading team but eventually rose to superintendent and worked in Ohio, Wisconsin, and Illinois. Langdon came to Saint Paul in 1858 and moved to Minneapolis in 1866. As a Minnesota contractor, Langdon built bridges, roads, buildings, and railways. He also served in the Minnesota Senate from 1873 to 1878, the time when he donated to Winchell’s casts, and from 1881 to 1886. Over his career, Langdon was credited with having built 7,000 miles of railway and at the time of his death was engaged in fulfilling a $3,000,000 contract for irrigation canals around Phoenix, Arizona. While in Phoenix, Langdon fell ill from cancer. He died after an extended, painful illness on July 24, 1895, and was buried in Lakewood Cemetery. Both Langdon, Minnesota and Langdon, North Dakota were named after him.
Henry Titus Welles
Henry Titus Welles was born on April 3, 1821, in Glastonbury, Connecticut and attended Trinity College before becoming a lawyer. In 1850, Welles was elected to the Connecticut General Assembly. In 1853 Welles moved to Saint Paul and shortly afterward visited Saint Anthony Falls and became enamored of the falls. He relocated to Saint Anthony and went into the lumber business with the city’s founder, Franklin Steele. In 1855, Welles was elected the first mayor of Saint Anthony. That same year, Welles and Steele built the first bridge across the Mississippi River, a suspension bridge from Minneapolis to Nicollet Island. In 1863, Welles was a candidate for governor but lost to Stephen Miller who would start both the first and second State Geological Surveys whose turmoil led to the third state survey under Winchell being run by the University of Minnesota. Welles was a successful capitalist involved in many banks and railroads, with large real estate holdings that included partial ownership of Col. John H. Stevens’ claim to the future site of Minneapolis. At the time of his death, Welles was among the richest men in the city with an estimated fortune of ten million dollars. He died at his mansion on Hennepin and 17th Avenue and was buried in Lakewood Cemetery.
Samuel Chester Gale
Samuel Chester Gale was born on September 15, 1827, in Royalston, Massachusetts. His father died when Gale was eleven and he was apprenticed to an uncle as a tanner. However, Gale wanted an education and at seventeen he entered New Salem Academy and went on to graduate from Yale and attend Harvard Law School. In 1857 Gale moved to Minneapolis and set up a law practice. In 1860 Gale began a real estate and loan company with his brother Harlow that eventually grew into one of city’s most prosperous businesses. Gale maintained his interest in education and helped found and lead the Minneapolis Athenaeum, a private subscription library. He later promoted Minneapolis’ public library and was on the Board of Education from 1871 to 1880. Gale was an alderman and president of the City Council and in 1866 helped build the Exposition Building and served as president of the Minneapolis Exposition. He was actively connected with Winchell’s Academy of Natural Sciences, the Minneapolis Society of Fine Arts, and the Board of Trade. Gale died on September 22, 1916, and was buried in Lakewood Cemetery.
Chute Brothers
Richard Fairchild Chute was born on September 23, 1820, in Cincinnati, Ohio and his brother Samuel Hewes Chute was born a decade later on December 6, 1830, in Columbus, Ohio. Both their parents died before Richard was fifteen, so he played a significant role in raising Samuel. In 1841, Richard began working as a clerk for the Indiana-based Ewing fur company and in 1844 was sent to Minnesota to build a fur trading post on the Minnesota River eight miles upstream of Fort Snelling. In 1845 he became a partner with the Ewings, and the firm became Ewing, Chute & Co. In 1854 Richard moved to St. Anthony, Minnesota, where he engaged in the real estate business and owned the St. Anthony Falls Water Power Company which controlled most of the waterpower on the east bank of the falls. Richard was a University of Minnesota regent from 1876 to 1882 and his son, Charles Chute, was one of the first students at the University, part of its inaugural scientific class. Samuel Chute followed Richard to Minneapolis, arriving in 1857 a few years after graduating from the Ohio Medical College in Cincinnati and working as a physician in Portland, Oregon. In 1865, the brothers formed a partnership, Chute Brothers, with dealings in real estate, mill sites, and waterpower. While Richard worked with the University, Samuel was one of the founders of the Minneapolis Public Schools. Richart died in Chicago on August 1, 1893, and Samuel in Milwaukee on October 12, 1913. Both were buried in Lakewood Cemetery.
Judge Isaac Atwater
Isaac Atwater was born on May 3, 1818, in Homer, New York. He graduated from Yale University, attended Yale Law School, and joined the New York bar in 1848. In October of 1850, Atwater moved to Saint Anthony, Minnesota Territory, hoping to improve his health and practice law. He purchased large land areas on the west bank of the Mississippi that became part of Minneapolis. Atwater also owned and published the St. Anthony Express newspaper. Atwood was one of the University of Minnesota’s first regents, serving from 1851 to 1860 and was a member of the Minneapolis City Council and board of education. In 1853, he was elected as district attorney for Hennepin County. Later, Atwater served on the first Minnesota Supreme Court from 1858 to 1864 and subsequently formed a legal partnership with Charles Flandrau. After 1886, Atwater ran a real estate business out of Minneapolis’ Kasota Building. He died on December 22, 1906, in his apartments in the West Hotel and was buried in Lakewood Cemetery.
Daniel Smith Storey
Daniel Smith Storey stood out in the cast donor list simply because he was of modest means. Rather than a wealthy capitalist or powerful politician, Storey sold lightning rods and fireproof paint. Yet in a 1909 Star Tribune article, Storey boasted he was ‘known by more people in Minneapolis than any other man living.’ Storey was born on September 10, 1823, in Lee, New York and attended Oneida Conference Seminary. After his family moved to Summit, Wisconsin in the 1840s, Storey married Susan Rose and they had five children. Their last child was born in 1862 shortly after they moved to Osage, Iowa where Storey was a land speculator. Susan died in 1867. Six years later, with most of his children on their own, Storey married Emmaline Victoria Johnson in Milwaukee, Wisconsin when she was twenty and he was fifty to begin a second family of five more children. Soon after their marriage, the couple moved to Minneapolis where Storey and a son from his first marriage made their living selling lightning rods and fireproof paint. The couple faced hurdles and divorced before 1900. Emmaline was committed to Saint Peter Hospital, the state’s mental hospital. She died there on January 29, 1908, and was buried in the hospital cemetery. It is not known how Storey came to be included in Winchell’s list of donors, but Storey claimed to have worked for four governors and to have installed lightning rods on every school in Minneapolis so he may have installed rods on Old Main. The balance that enabled Storey to work on roofs and spires undoubtedly was the reason he was known as an expert dancer even at the age of 86. Storey died on January 3, 1914. While most of Winchell’s donors were interred in Lakewood Cemetery, Storey died in Summit, Wisconsin and was buried there.
Jonathan Chase
Jonathan Chase was born in Sebec, Maine, on December 31, 1817. He worked in Maine’s lumber industry for twenty years before coming to Saint Anthony in 1853, about the time that he married Melissa Pollard of Masardis, Maine. Chase focused on harvesting lumber along the Rum and Upper Mississippi rivers. He built mills at Gull River and a lumber yard in Minneapolis. Chase was a member of Minnesota’s last territorial legislature and in 1859 became a senator in the first state legislature. At the beginning of the civil war he enlisted in Company A, Ninth Minnesota infantry as first lieutenant. Within a few months, he was promoted to captain and served under the command of Gen. Henry Hastings Sibley. He served under Sibley during the Dakota War but had to resign in 1863 because of poor health. Chase died in his home at 607 Seventh Street SE, on February 1, 1904, and was buried in Lakewood Cemetery. Chase Lake in Itasca County was named after him.
Anthony Kelly
Anthony Kelly was born on August 25, 1832, in Swinford, County Mayo, Ireland. When he was fifteen, his family moved to Canada, close to Montreal. Kelly later moved to Georgia and worked as a planter until coming to Minneapolis in 1858. Kelly followed his brother, Peter, who had arrived the previous year. The two brothers opened a retail grocery store on Washington Avenue, just south of Second Avenue South. They later moved their store to the west side of Hennepin Avenue. In 1863, Patrick left to open a wholesale grocery house in Saint Paul and Kelly took sole ownership of the Minneapolis store eventually turning it into a wholesale concern with a new stone headquarters building on Washington and Second Avenue North. Apart from Pillsbury’s hardware business, at the time of his death, Kelly’s store was the oldest in the city. While many of the other cast donors fought for the Union, Kelly was an ardent southern sympathizer due to his time as a Georgia planter. Kelly died on May 31, 1899, of heart disease and rheumatism. The lone Catholic among Winchell’s donors, Kelly was buried in Minneapolis’ Saint Mary’s Cemetery. In his will, Kelly left the archdiocese $10,000 to help build DeLaSalle High School on Nicollet Island.
Wyman Elliot
Wyman Elliot was born on May 19, 1834, in Corinna, Maine. Elliot arrived in Minnesota in 1854 with his parents and for much of his life worked in horticulture. His father, Dr. Jacob S. Elliot, donated Elliot Park to the city and his brother, Dr. A. F. Elliot, funded the university’s Elliot Memorial Hospital. When his father turned to medicine, Elliott took over the family farm developing it into a nursery and garden. The farm stretched from Eighth Street to Franklin Avenue, between Chicago and Eleventh Avenue. Its northeastern corner became Minneapolis’ present Elliot Park. By 1862, Elliott had established the first market garden in Minneapolis, two greenhouses, and a tree nursery. In 1864, Elliot was one of the founders of the Hennepin County Horticultural Society and later of the state horticultural society. Elliot served as city park commissioner from 1899-1901 and invented new varieties of apples, including the Pride of Minneapolis in 1855. Well known for his love of roses, Wyman helped create Lake Harriet’s Lyndale Park Rose Gardens. Elliot died at his home at 1412 West Forty-Seventh Street on June 16, 1913. In good health, he died unexpectedly in his rose garden, working among the flowers he loved. Like most Winchell donors, he was buried in Lakewood Cemetery.
Thomas Lowry
Thomas Lowry was born on February 27, 1843, in Logan County, Illinois and came to Minneapolis in 1867 after joining the bar. Beginning as a lawyer, Lowry soon shifted his focus to real estate and land speculation. In 1875, he joined the Minneapolis Street Railway Company and by 1877 held a controlling interest. Lowry pushed to expand Minneapolis’ streetcar lines out to surrounding undeveloped areas where he held extensive land tracts.
Lowry gained control of the Saint Paul City Railway and merged his companies together in 1891 to create the Twin City Rapid Transit Company, which became a driving force in the two cities’ development. Lowry was also the president of what became the Soo Line Railroad from 1889 to 1890 and from 1892 to 1909. His son, Horace, took over the Twin City Rapid Transit and ran it until his own death in 1931. Lowry died on February 4, 1909, at his home in Minneapolis and was buried at the Lowry mausoleum in Lakewood Cemetery. Lowry Memorial, Thomas Lowry Park, and Lowry Hill Tunnel are all named after him.
Hon. Abram McCellan Reid
Abraham McCellan Reid was born on January 28, 1830, in Greene County, Ohio. As a young man, he engaged in manufacturing and the general merchandise business for fifteen years. Despite being married, he enlisted during the Civil War and was a sargent in an Ohio company. After the war, Reid decided to move west and toured many large cities west of the Mississippi, before deciding to bring his family to Minneapolis in 1865. Five years later, Reid partnered with Anthony Kelly, another cast donor, to form Kelly, Reid, & Wagner wholesale grocers. He was also one of the founders and later president of North Star Boot and Shoe Company. Reid was a strong promoter of the Brush Electric Company of Saint Anthony Falls, the first commercial producer of hydroelectric power in the nation. Reid served terms in both the Ohio and Minnesota legislatures and was a Minneapolis city alderman. In his later years, Reid became invalid and spent his last twenty winters in New Mexico and Arizona. In April of 1898, he became ill and returned to Minneapolis, dying on May 6. Like most of Winchell’s donors, he was buried in Lakewood Cemetery.
Hon. Abram (Abraham) McCellan Reid house (from Once There Were Castles by Larry Millett).
Hon. Paris Gibson
Paris Gibson was born on July 1, 1830, in Brownfield, Maine. He graduated from Bowdoin College in 1851 and two years later was elected to the Maine legislature. In August of 1858, Gibson married Valeria G. Sweat and the couple moved to Saint Anthony Falls in 1859. Gibson was one of the founders of Cataract Mill, the first flourmill in Minneapolis, as well as the North Star Woolen Mill. He helped establish Minneapolis’ first public library and served on the University of Minnesota’s Board of Regents from 1871 through 1879. In 1879 Gibson moved to Montana as a sheep rancher. In 1883 Gibson was elected the first president of the Montana Wool Growers Association and continued in that office for 22 years through Montana’s ‘Sheep Wars’. In 1885 Gibson relocated to Great Falls, Montana. Impressed with the falls’ waterpower, he determined to replicate his earlier success at Saint Anthony Falls and founded the Great Falls Water Power and Townsite Company. Gibson purchased the town site, built a power company, hotel, and recruited settlers, building Great Falls, Montana. The town’s population grew from 100 in 1885 to over 4,000 in 1890. Gibson enticed a railroad line to the town in 1887 and became a director of its First National Bank. In 1888 Great Falls was incorporated as a city and Gibson was elected the first mayor. Gibson’s Great Falls Light and Power Co. built transmission lines throughout the region as well as a dam on the Missouri River at Black Eagle in 1890. That same year he co-founded the Boston and Montana Smelter Company in Great Falls, which became the major smelter for Butte copper. In 1912, his power company merged with others to form the Montana Power Company. In 1889 Gibson represented Cascade County at the State Constitutional Convention and served as a member of the Montana Senate. In 1901, at the age of 71, the state legislature elected him a U.S. Senator. He served until 1905. Gibson died on December 16, 1920, and as fitting for the founder of Great Falls, was buried there.